After the Spokesman-Review cut ties with longtime editor Rob Curley last Friday, the board of the nonprofit Curley founded to absorb Spokane’s daily newspaper declined to do the same — seemingly killing the planned transfer.
In a message sent to donors Tuesday afternoon, Comma Journalism Lab said the Cowles Company informed Comma that the Spokesman-Review would not be donated as long as Curley remained involved. That same day, the Comma board had taken a vote declining the newspaper’s donation and opted to keep Curley on instead.
“We can't build Rob's model without Rob. And no charity's board should let a donor decide who leads it," said George Brunt, Comma’s board chair, in a statement to InvestigateWest and RANGE. "The Spokesman-Review is free to become a nonprofit on its own terms, and we wish its journalists well.”
The Spokesman-Review reported that the Cowles Company will retain ownership of the newspaper. Managing Editor Lindsey Treffry will continue at the helm of the newsroom, a role she has held since Curley was suspended in early August.
Over a dozen former and current employees voiced serious workplace complaints to InvestigateWest and RANGE about Curley’s leadership, including his perceived lack of journalistic integrity and retaliation against some employees. Spokesman-Review staff have opposed Comma’s plan to keep Curley on board.
Curley’s “departure” from the newsroom was due to “differences over the Company’s core values, policies and code of conduct,” said Publisher William “Stacey” Cowles in a statement sent Tuesday. He did not specify what those differences were or if Curley was ultimately fired or if he resigned.
The Spokesman’s union, the Spokane Editorial Society, said in a statement that it "applauded” the news of Curley’s departure. Union president Thomas Clouse praised Cowles for his “courage to defend the wellbeing of his employees” against the Comma board members who refused to split from Curley at the expense of the partnership.
Though the union acknowledged some of Curley’s successes, like his ability to grow the newsroom for a time, it also made note of his tenure being “marred by scores of unkept promises and lies,” and the hostile work environment he created.
Comma’s message to donors, which InvestigateWest and RANGE reviewed, detailed its belief that Curley is “essential” to executing the vision of a community-owned daily newspaper, a project that has been years in the making. Hopeful for the vision that had been laid out, more than 800 donors shelled out over $2 million — a figure the Cowles Company had previously pledged to match in addition to transferring the paper.
In its statement, the nonprofit said it would “continue its work,” which includes managing the Northwest Passages events highlighting the work of authors and journalists.
“Over the next few weeks we'll contact each of you about your options, including directing your gift to Comma's continuing work. We won't collect any outstanding pledge payment until we've heard from you,” the message to donors said.
Moving forward, Cowles said that the two parties will have to develop a written agreement regarding the event series.
Comma said the investigation into Curley found no instances of discrimination, sexual harassment, dishonesty or mishandling of money. But those findings have not been made public. The Spokesman-Review reported that while no violations of state or federal laws were found, the investigation did find “code of conduct issues.”
Still, Comma told donors it didn't find anything that justified firing Curley, who remains listed as a member of the Comma board.
Curley expressed his gratitude in the Comma statement for those who have supported the model he proposed and for the Spokesman journalists, calling their work “extraordinary.”
"Community-owned local news is too important to give up on, and I'm not giving up on it," he said.
The Comma board has seen other changes in recent months: What was once a board of 11 members has been reduced to seven. Recent departures from the board include Comma donor David Barbieri and Rick Williams, who is the brother of late civil rights activist Sandy Williams. Rick Williams did not respond to requests for comment.
Speaking from Manchester, England, Barbieri said he left the board because the responsibilities became demanding before he moved abroad and he no longer felt like he could “deliver like I needed to” in the role. He said he still held hope that the vision for a community-owned paper materialized.
Journalism serves a valuable purpose, Barbieri said.
"So it's unfortunate that disagreements happen in the process of trying to accomplish that. It's horrible when personalities get in the way of progress," he added. “I hope that all of these people working to make sure that journalism thrives can figure out a way to align on a plan that causes it to.”
InvestigateWest (investigatewest.org) is an independent news nonprofit dedicated to investigative journalism in the Pacific Northwest. RANGE is a worker-owned newsroom covering Spokane and the greater Inland Northwest. Contact Wilson Criscione at wilson@investigatewest.org and Daisy Zavala Magaña at daisy@rangemedia.co.