> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.rangemedia.co/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Switched at Death
- URL: https://www.rangemedia.co/spokane-county-medical-examiner-mixup/
- Published: 2026-11-21T00:21:23.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-21T00:21:23.000Z
- Description: The Spokane County Medical Examiner’s office told a family their son was dead. He wasn’t.
- Author: Daniel Walters
- Tags: Government

Tricia Root’s son was dead. 

This was the message her family had been given from the medical examiner’s office on February 17\. It’s the call that every parent of someone living on the street dreads: one from a doctor, a cop, or a coroner. 

“You have it in your head that’s going to be coming — that phone call is going to be coming — but you’re never prepared,” Tricia said. 

When the medical examiner’s office in Spokane reached her at her Arizona home, she had trouble even talking. Her roommate had to take the phone for part of it. It took her two hours to write the text to her sister because she was crying so much. 

Jeremy Root — one of the [subjects](https://www.rangemedia.co/stabbed-frostbitten-overdosed-sheltered-sober-saved/) of our three-year series following the lives of three homeless people we met in 2023 at the Spokane library — had survived a stabbing, frostbite, getting hit by multiple cars and living on the street off and on for more than a decade. 

But he’d been found dead that morning, in his sleeping bag on a Downtown Spokane fire escape. 

“His body can be released whenever I am ready, but who is ever ready for that!?” she wrote in a message to her sister. 

The toxicology report would take weeks, but she knew damn well what it was: a drug overdose. Jeremy struggled with mental health and drug use for years, and he’d been found with drug paraphernalia next to his body.

When she'd had a heart attack two years ago, she’d begged the people in her ambulance, “you can’t let me die. I have to find my son.” 

But as the waves of grief crashed into her, she wished to herself that she had died right then and there instead, so she wouldn’t have to feel the pain of losing her son, so that — if there was an afterlife — they would be reunited. 

Everything was a fog. She wanted to vomit. 

Her son was dead. 

*But then.* 

But then, the next day, the medical examiner’s office left another voicemail. It said there was a chance the office made a mistake, that they may have misidentified the body as her son’s. They’d let her know for sure when they could. 

For two days, she was suspended in agonizing uncertainty, not knowing if her son was alive. 

“I am a nervous wreck,” she wrote in a text to her sister. “I have to call my doctor to get something to calm me down. My hands shake so much. This is a fucking nightmare.” 

The verdict came down February 20: Tricia Root’s son was alive; some other mother’s son was dead. And after the initial flood of emotions, she was left with a sense of deep anger over what they did to her. 

“It was just an *emotional trauma*,” Tricia said. “I can't even describe how it feels. It's a pain I've never in life had.” 

Now, she said, she’s looking for lawyers to talk to about suing the medical examiner’s office over the case. She doesn’t want anyone, ever, to have to go through this again. 

To the medical examiner’s office, the mix-up was a 1 in 10,000 kind of fluke, caused when a lookalike was found dead beside a bottle of Jeremy’s medication. But figuring out the body wasn’t Jeremy shouldn’t have been hard, his mother said. 

“Every cop in town knows him,” Tricia said. "His fingerprints are everywhere.” 

But the medical examiner’s office hadn’t actually run the fingerprints on the body before they called her to tell her that her son was dead. She wonders, "If he wasn't homeless and into the drug scene, would they have handled it that way?"

### **The Death and Resurrection of Jeremy Root** 

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/e7/35e7a6d5-1d7d-405c-9ee3-dce92dfd190f/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-c053fb29-63ba-46bc-bf02-7eb10cbf05f9.jpeg)

**The fire escape at the back of the Holley Mason building downtown. On February 17, a dead body — originally identified as Jeremy Root — was found at the top. (Photo by Daniel Walters)*

The crisp February air was hovering just above freezing the Tuesday morning when security guard Elvin Bermudez came across the dead body in the black bag. 

The fire escape in the back of the Holley Mason building in Downtown Spokane is easy enough to scale — the stairs in the back go up three stories and don’t require any acrobatics to access. When the air gets cold, the ground gets colder. Surviving means putting distance between yourself and the icy ground. 

With used fentanyl foils and a rolled-up bill next to the body, it sure looked a lot like an overdose. 

Bermudez was hardly the first security guard for GoJoe Patrol, the company contracted to guard the Holley Mason building, to run across a dead body downtown. 

Over 280 people in Spokane County died of drug overdoses last year, and more than 100 of them were homeless. 

Bermudez, who’d spent years as a police officer at Eastern Washington University, dialed 911\. He explained he’d found a body — a man in his mid-30s. He knew it was too late to help. 

First the cops came, then the fire department, and finally the medical investigator, James Uttke. 

Uttke is an old pro at this. He’s used to dealing with death: the gore, the smells, the grief. 

He's been working for the Spokane County Medical Examiner since 2001\. He’s seen technology transform the profession, where DNA advances have allowed them to exhume bodies and solve 50-year-old cold cases.

By now, Uttke has over 18,000 cases under his belt. In all that time, he said, he'd only made a misidentification once, and that time it was because a survivor of a car accident lied about the identity of one of the other victims. 

In this case, the stiffness of the body indicated he’d been dead for hours. But one of the cops was sure he recognized him. 

Downtown police are on a first-name basis with Jeremy Root**.** He was on the list of the “Downtown 10,” the top 10 people that cops, paramedics and other social services agencies were responding to more than any other. That very month, cops had arrested Jeremy a few blocks away for illegally camping near the Adams Street viaduct. 

The police officers pulled up Jeremy’s jail booking photo on their department laptop, and Uttke and them started making comparisons. The face on the dead body looked a whole lot like the face in the photo. Weight. Hair color. Facial hair. The size and shape of the nose. The hazel eyes. 

The clincher was what was next to the body, inside the blue backpack: a bottle of prescription medication with a name on it. “Jeremy Root.”

“Usually if we have any doubt, we leave it as an ‘unidentified male,’ with the date and the location, and then we wait for scientific means,” Uttke later told RANGE. 

But in this case, Uttke was confident it was Root. He had the police ID, the booking photo and the pill bottle. 

But those who really knew Jeremy would have seen red flags. There were burnt fentanyl foils beside the body. Jeremy used meth but took pride in not using fentanyl — he’d seen too many people on the street die that way. The body was 5’11\. Jeremy was 6’0\. The body had a full sleeve of green and black tattoos on the left arm. Jeremy didn’t. 

But even before the body’s fingerprints were sent to the county forensics unit to analyze, Uttke reached out to Jeremy’s mother. He's used to making these phone calls. Apologize up front. Stay blunt and factual. Don't try to dress up the death with vague language like “they passed along” or “they're no longer with us.” Euphemisms can’t dull the pain. 

As Tricia was left reeling, her family did what they could. 

“I can’t imagine the pain you are in and my heart breaks for you, Tricia,” Kate Ross, Tricia’s sister, wrote in a text message. “Please stay strong as I love having you in my life.” 

Ross offered to drive to Spokane to help take care of the body, and find a funeral home. Jeremy’s cousins discussed launching a GoFundMe to help prepare for the funeral. 

Meanwhile, back in Spokane, the bureaucratic machine was humming along: The police wrote up their report with Jeremy’s name. The body was set for an autopsy. Prints were taken. With a red “WARRANT RECALLED” stamp, a Spokane Municipal Court quashed the warrant that had been issued for Jeremy’s failure to appear in court. The police stopped looking for him. 

But he was found anyway. 

Just one day after he’d been pronounced dead, street medics and employees of homeless service providers both contacted the police saying they saw Jeremy looking very-much-alive. One of the officers who’d responded to the Holley Mason scene decided to double check. He walked into the medical examiner’s office, took a closer look at the tattoos that ran down the body’s left arm. They weren’t Jeremy’s tattoos. He thought he knew who the body really was. 

But this time Uttke was cautious about leaping to conclusions. 

“We have had times where we've gotten reports that, ‘Oh, someone saw someone after they were deceased,’ and then it ended up being false,” Uttke said. 

The medical examiner’s office first reached Ross, Jeremy’s aunt, to tell her they may have made a mistake. 

“My mind's going 'God, what if I'd had this funeral company come and pick up the body and cremated him, and then two months down the road we find out it wasn’t him,” Ross said. “What parent out there doesn't know that their child has died? I mean, I was just *aghast*.”

She said she pleaded with them to not tell her sister until they knew for sure. Ross didn’t want to get her hopes up. 

“They left a voice message on her frigging phone, telling her that it might not be Jeremy,” Ross said. “So she went through days of absolute hell not knowing if it was him.”

According to county records, the body’s fingerprints had been forwarded to the Spokane County Sheriff's Forensic Unit, on Wednesday, February 19, the day after the death was reported. The lab processed them the same day, concluding the body wasn’t Jeremy. 

But that report wasn’t officially finalized by the lab for two days. According to the Forensic Unit, agencies can request that fingerprinting reports be given priority to finish them faster. That wasn’t done in this case. 

On Friday, February 20, three days after Jeremy’s death was proclaimed, he was officially pronounced alive by the Spokane County Medical Examiner’s office. 

"So I'm not dead," Jeremy Root posted that day on Facebook.

He’d gone to Shalom Ministries, a nonprofit that feeds the hungry, and a bunch of people were hugging him, telling him they’d been told he’d died. 

**“**Holy cow, dude,” one friend replied. “Well, I'm glad you're on this side of the dirt."

It’s not clear how Root’s meds ended up in someone else’s backpack — whether they were stolen, bought, traded for or found. In August, Root told RANGE he was willing to be interviewed for this story but wanted to check with his family first. Attempts to reach him again were unsuccessful.

Johnathan Waldrop, operations manager for the Spokane County Medical Examiner, said the body wouldn’t have actually been released to the family until they had scientifically confirmed the identity. 

There’s a balance about when to tell family members about the death of their loved one. 

“We were just trying to be proactive and just trying to let people know in a timely manner, rather than wait a few days,” Waldrop said. The last thing a family wants is to first hear about their relative’s death on social media. 

But Tricia feels raw about how she was treated. 

“I never got a letter saying they were sorry,” Tricia said. “It was just like, 'oh, go away.’ Like they pretended it didn't happen.” 

Uttke said he tried to call Jeremy's mom and her sister, but they didn't answer or return the call. 

“I'm not going to keep, you know, bugging her, just so I can say I'm sorry,” Uttke said. “I wish I could have talked to her to explain how things happened.”

What would he tell her if he could? 

“I'm sorry,” Uttke told RANGE. “It was my mistake. There's not much more that I can say. It was my mistake."

Uttke says that, personally, he’s no longer going to make exceptions: In situations like this, keep bodies classified as “unidentified” until they can be identified scientifically. 

Elsewhere, misidentification mistakes have put counties in legal jeopardy. 

In 2017 in Orange County, a family buried someone they he thought was their son, only for the son to show up alive a few weeks later. The coroner’s office claimed they had fingerprint evidence but had mistakenly relied on an old driver’s license photo. The family sued and the jury awarded them $1.5 million — though that verdict was [overturned last year](https://www.ocregister.com/2025/02/10/order-for-new-trial-affirmed-in-suit-over-oc-officials-mistakenly-telling-a-father-and-sister-a-family-member-had-died/?ref=rangemedia.co) by a judge. 

Root doesn’t know whether she has a strong enough case to sue. But she can’t even feel a sense of relief that they were wrong about Jeremy’s death without a pang of guilt. The fact that her son is alive means that someone else’s son died that cold morning. 

“I'm so happy, but somebody else is not,” Tricia said. “So how can I be joyful when I know somebody else's heart is breaking?” 

She’d never been told the name of the man who had died instead. Sometimes, she wondered who it had been — what other grieving family’s fate had become mistakenly intertwined with her son’s?

### Every Body’s Somebody

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/e7/35e7a6d5-1d7d-405c-9ee3-dce92dfd190f/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-facade97-aaf0-4389-88ca-bd2920075f78.jpeg)

**Pictures throughout the years of Michael Bargel, a homeless man who was found dead on February 17\. (Photos courtesy of Tiana Ribeiro Goelz)*

Michael Bargel “could pretty much do anything that he ever put his hands on,” his sister, Tiana Ribeiro Goelz, recalls.

She remembers taking two years to learn to snowboard — and then her brother tried it and, bam, he was snowboarding on the terrain park from day one. Her little brother, born smack-dab in the middle of five kids, could bowl a 300-point game. He loved to play basketball and fish. He was artistic too: He drew the tattoo — the stylized word “faith” embedded within an ornate green-and-black design — that covered his left arm. 

You can see him in the 2008 North Central High School yearbook: a skinny kid wearing a “Groovy Shoes” basketball competition T-shirt, elected “Most Spirited” by his senior classmates. Back then, his sister remembers, he was “wicked smart.” Tiana, today an energy transmission analyst, used to compete with him to see who could get the best grades. 

Four years later, Ribeiro Goelz found herself screaming outside an apartment complex door at the woman who had introduced Michael to OxyContin. She was trying to save her brother. 

Addiction warped the arc of Michael’s life. Addiction left him battered with bruises in the back alleys of a Nevada mining town; hounded by debt collectors for unpaid utility bills; surrounded by broken dishes and glass figurines in his mom’s living room; diagnosed with “opioid use disorder” and "unspecified schizophrenia spectrum disorder” in psychiatrists’ offices. Addiction cost him housing and jobs and his mother’s trust and custody of his baby boy. It sent him to jail, to Eastern State Hospital and then — up three stories of the fire escape on the Holley Mason, inside a black sleeping bag beside burnt fentanyl foils and a rolled-up twenty and a pill bottle with another man’s name — to his end, unbreathing and unknown. 

"It sounds like this other family went through hell," Ribeiro Goelz told RANGE after we shared Tricia’s story. "But so did we.” 

The final chapter of Michael Bargel’s life began in May 2025 in the Sunset Food Mart, where he’d kicked out the glass in the front door, and walked away with cookies and a few pints of Ben & Jerry’s. He was charged with burglary, but the court concluded he was unable to understand the charges against him and he was sent to Eastern State Hospital. 

But inside the mental hospital, as illicit drugs were replaced with carefully prescribed ones, the fog began to lift. He began to speak more clearly. It was like the pieces in his damaged brain were being connected back together. 

“When he was sober and not on drugs, you could see his heart,” his cousin Zach Holland told RANGE. “Who he was shined through."

He started talking about getting his gold mining job back, about getting healthy, leaving the hospital and staying clean so he could see his son. 

“Anytime we saw him and he was of sound mind, he would say, ‘I'm going to see my son. I'm going to get better for my son,” Ribeiro Goelz said. 

But getting better had a big downside: It meant leaving the sanctuary of the Eastern State Hospital. Bargel was transferred to an American Behavioral Health Systems treatment home in Spokane Valley. Ribeiro Goelz thought it was a safe move, that her brother wouldn’t be able to simply leave on a whim. 

The long-term plan for him was to get a spot at a bed at Magnolia Care, an assisted care facility. He never made it there. Less than two weeks into his stay at the treatment home, he checked himself out. His family was never told that he had left. 

It was exactly the kind of outcome that experts warned about in his court file. 

"If he were to return to an unstable living situation or disengage from mental health services, the lack of oversight and constancy would result in increased risk,” forensic evaluator Ana Alberti warned in court documents last November. 

A few weeks later, he was spotted outside his aunt’s house. Ribeiro Goelz said her brother’s face looked heavy with the signs of recent drug use. She offered her brother the spare room at her house if he could be sober, but he refused. He told her he wanted to get high “just one more time, sis.” 

He was a grown man. Without a court order, his family was helpless to stop him from doing anything. 

So instead, the big sister gave her little brother a sleeping bag and a coat and packed him a backpack with socks, handwarmers and food. She dropped him off near the Shadle Park Walmart, and stood with him near a park bench and pleaded with him one last time. 

“Michael, please, Michael please, please just come home,” she remembers saying. 

The brother shook his head no. The sister hugged him, and cried. 

“I love you little brother,” the sister said. “I love you, little brother.” 

And then she had to leave him. Six days later, Michael Bargel was found dead. Three days after that, the medical examiner’s office reached out to his family. At first, Ribeiro Goelz struggled with it. 

“Are you fucking sure?” Ribeiro Goelz said. “How do I know it’s my brother?”

Dental records, the voice on the other end of the line said. Nobody told her they’d gotten the ID wrong the first time. 

But Ribeiro Goelz wanted to see the body in person to be sure. 

“I want to be able to say, 'Yep, that's my brother.’ It's not like his face was destroyed, right?’ she said. “I could identify him by the face.”

The medical examiner’s office wouldn’t do that. That scene in TV shows where a family member comes into the morgue to confirm that the dead body belongs to their loved one doesn’t happen in Spokane. They aren’t set up for that. 

All they could do was transfer the body to a funeral home, and she could see him there. 

Viewing the body of your loved one is just one more fee that funeral homes tack on to the bill. 

“Now we're paying a funeral home a fee just to even say ‘Yes, that's him,” Ribeiro Goelz said. 

One place wanted $700 for the luxury, Ribeiro Goelz said. She ultimately found a funeral home that charged $375\. 

There the sister stood, in a funeral home not so far from the convenience store where Michael had stolen the ice cream the year before, alone in the room with her brother’s body. The body looked like him — no one else — just her brother, Michael. 

“It was actually really beautiful,” she said. 

The sister held her brother’s hand, and talked to him, laughing and crying, telling him she loved him, and that she knew he was amazing, no matter what anyone said. 

His body was burned to ash. And one evening on the Oregon coast, in two overlapping hearts etched in the sand, those ashes were buried with the ashes of Michael’s mother. The sister sat in the dusk and watched, as waves slowly lapped over the shore, washing away the hearts and carrying the ash out to sea. 

### Still breathing

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/e7/35e7a6d5-1d7d-405c-9ee3-dce92dfd190f/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-96926c4c-674c-469a-ae5a-b80ae367890b.jpeg)

**While at sober housing in May, Jeremy Root emphasized that many people addicted to drugs may relapse many times while trying to get clean — but that can often be part of the sobriety process. (Photo by Daniel Walters)*

In March, records show, internal police department emails requested that Jeremy Root’s “warrants be re-issued in accordance with the subject’s continued existence.” 

Jeremy was arrested, but the court agreed to release him from jail, with a condition attached: he would go to rehab. And this time, Root agreed. 

Back in May, RANGE sat down with Jeremy Root out front of a sober living house on the South Hill. 

“This is my first actual attempt at trying not to do drugs, really," he told RANGE in May. "I feel better than I have in a long time.”

He didn’t mention the death of his lookalike when talking about the decision to pursue sobriety. But he did talk a lot about how deadly homelessness had become, particularly in the age of fentanyl. 

“Motherfuckers who have been doing this shit for decades, they hit that foil twice, and you never see them again,” Root said. 

The 286 drug overdose deaths in Spokane County last year is 10% fewer than in 2024, but remained far higher than any other year before that. That doesn’t include the dozens more who have been brought back from the brink of death by Narcan. 

Uttke, the medical investigator, says these deaths need to be treated as sacredly as any other. 

“Everybody is someone's child. Everybody's someone's brother. Everybody is someone's sister,” Uttke said. “I don't care about who they were in life as far as how we treat them. Everybody deserves our respect.”

But to the public, these drug overdose deaths can become a kind of white noise, part of an urban reality that downtown visitors literally sidestep. Their deaths rarely make headlines except in aggregate statistics in stories about homelessness or the opioid epidemic

Every year in late December, CHAS, a low-income healthcare nonprofit, holds a memorial ceremony for the homeless men and women who died the year before. RANGE reached out to CHAS to request that Michael Bargel’s name would be part of it this year, and that Ribeiro Goelz be invited to the ceremony. 

To the families of those who died on the streets, these deaths leave deep wounds, the grief lanced through with guilt. 

“I feel like I should have just forced the motherfucker to stay at my house,” Ribeiro Goelz said of her brother. 

Tricia can truly relate — for three days, she’d truly experienced the pain of Michael’s death as if it happened to her own son. 

“I understand that their child’s death is after probably years of trying to save their life,” Tricia wrote in a text. 

It’s why she wrote to Ribeiro Goelz, after RANGE connected them, asking if there was anything she could do to ease their pain. 

“I have wondered about your family and the pain I know you are going through,” Tricia wrote. She shared that her own brother, many years ago, had died of an overdose too. 

“These are unfortunate circumstances for our paths to cross, but I also think leaning in on one another's stories and the impact it had on both of us is something we share a bond over," Ribeiro Goelz wrote. "I'm here if you ever want to talk."

Considering all his brushes with death, Jeremy has sometimes greeted the question of his own mortality with a shrug. 

“I've definitely lived a full life,” Jeremy said in May. “If I were to die tomorrow, I really wouldn't have any complaints.”

But his mother doesn’t feel that way. She heard from Jeremy in early October. But there are times, when Tricia hasn’t heard from Jeremy in many months, that she worries that he’s using again. She fears that the call she got in February was just a trial run, a taste of how she’d feel if her son actually dies of an overdose. 

She worries someday it really will be her son’s body found on some fire escape, stumbled across by a security guard, investigated, identified, autopsied. And then she’ll get the call, for real this time, and the voice will be sympathetic but serious, and she’ll have to make the decisions with the funeral home — cremated or buried — and decide whether to pay the extra fee to see his body. 

“It makes it worse knowing how awful it will be,” Tricia said. 

Her son could still die. That is the fear she will always hold. Her son is alive. That is the hope she can still cling to**.** 

“I failed Jeremy in many ways,” Tricia said. “But not for a minute do I regret having him as my son.” 

[Stabbed. Frostbitten. Overdosed. Sheltered. Sober. Saved.In 2023, I interviewed three unhoused men at the Spokane library. Over the next three years, all of them escaped homelessness![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/e7/35e7a6d5-1d7d-405c-9ee3-dce92dfd190f/content/images/icon/8-73b44a65-0b87-4ccd-97df-c81f777d70f7.png)RANGE MediaDaniel Walters![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/e7/35e7a6d5-1d7d-405c-9ee3-dce92dfd190f/content/images/thumbnail/3-2-606ad2d6-2eb8-407d-8824-5ed2ee880797.png)](https://www.rangemedia.co/stabbed-frostbitten-overdosed-sheltered-sober-saved/)